IsIt Necessary to Offer English Course to Ph D Students?
Thereis much controversy nowadays about whether or not Ph. D students, who have beenlearning English for years since the middle school, need to be offered Englishlearning course or courses. Some people say that students should not proceedwith English learning at this stage. But there are others who claim thatEnglish should still be a compulsory course even for Ph. D students.
Thosewho agree to stop English courses argue that students have been learning basicEnglish skills for years. They have had a good command of grammar. Therefore,it is not necessary to waste their precious time learning English class. TheirEnglish proficiency can be improved by reading books and journals in theirresearch fields.
Thosewho criticize this point of view maintain that intensive language training isstill necessary. Although it is true that most of the students English for morethan ten years, lots of them are still shy when speaking English in public andwhat is worse, lots of them cannot express themselves well. This greatlyhinders their academic communication with foreign experts.
Thereis certainly some truth on both sides. But in my opinion English is a veryimportant tool for would-be scientists and a half-year course will greatlybenefit their future research.